Muddle the Mixture 2: Augstralian Kangafrog

Up: So this is actualy a I & II ability, right? It doesn't need two separate boxes. This looks really strong, especially because of the haste + menace. Yet I think it's still fair game. It's a really nice use of the saga mecanic.

Crackling Dog
Creature - Hound
Whenever Crackling Dog becomes the target of a spell or ability an opponent controls, Crackling Dog deals 2 damage to that player.
3/2

Next: Calciderm + Wall of Brambles

Up: An obvious combination, but a good one.

Speaking of obvious combinations:
Crusher Wurm 
Creature - Wurm
When CARDNAME enters the battlefield, destroy target creature with defender, then you may flip a coin. If you win the flip, return CARDNAME to your hand.
5/5

Next: Kitsune Bonesetter + Dromar, the Banisher

Ümbraz, Abyssal Artisan 
Legendary Creature - "Human" Shaman
Haste
At the beginning of your upkeep, you may sacrifice two creatures. When you do, exile target nonland permanent.
2/2

Next: False Prophet + Boros Signet

Up: A land with mana cost is quite the weirdness. I think this would make more sense as an artifact. The effect is quite powerful. Also it kind of violates the color pie. It ramps you two mana with CMC 3. This is ok in green, but not in white. And land destruction is something white did back in the days, but not anymore.
And you can make mana and rarity symols by putting them between double colons. Read this for more info.

Not much to work here with. Let's see...

Dawnspinner
Creature - Spider
Vigilance, haste, reach
Dawnspinner can block only creatures with flying.
5/5

Next: Shared Triumph + Fertilid

Up: In its current state it could really be a common or uncommon. Honestly, in most situations it would be worse than regular Fertilid, but it's still an interesting design.

Plight of the Returned
Enchantment - Saga
Whenever an opponent draws a card, ~ deals 1 damage to that player.

I - Each player discards their hand.

II & III - Each player draws two cards.


Taken from the Theros Returned who give up their memories to return to the living, but still can't fully integrate in society.

Next: Jubilant Mascot + Razor Golem

Up: Affinity for +1/+1 counters is neat design space that I can totally see actually happening in a set made by Wizards in the future. I also like that the support ability makes future copies cheaper. You're missing a rarity, but this feels like a decent rare. 8/10

Burnclaw
Artifact - Equipment
Whenever equipped creature deals damage to a permanent or player, put a charge counter on Burnclaw.
, remove five charge counters from Burnclaw: Burnclaw deals 5 damage to any target.
Equip

Next: Cytoplast Root-kin + Stolen Goods

Up: Oh, that's quite cool! Not sure I like the fact that Graft doesn't do much on this creature; maybe I'd prefer if it did something to your creatures with +1/+1 counters on them? 

Underdark Tinkerer
Artifact Creature - Wizard  
Tap two untapped artifacts you control: Each player draws a card. 
He found wisdom where others found wealth. 
2/2

Next: Merfolk Looter + Skullclamp

Up: I really, really like this. Not much to say really, just a fun card that combines the two quite nicely. 10/10

Dromoka's Warcaller
Creature - Human Shaman
CARDNAME enters the battlefield with a +1/+1 counter on it for each face-down creature you control.
When CARDNAME dies, manifest the top X cards of your library, where X is the number of +1/+1 counters in CARDNAME.
2/2

Next: Keldon Halberdier + Death Baron

Up: this muddle feels good! It carries the first strike and the sort of tribal component from both cards, which are the biggest pieces of both. Generally just very good

This muddle is a bit difficult because the effects are so different hmmmm

Rambunctious Aegis
Creature - Dog Spirit
Cumulative Upkeep
Whenever you take damage that would reduce your life total to less than 1, the damage reduces your life total to 1 instead and you may destroy target artifact or enchantment.
0/4

I tried to use a steep cumulative upkeep to make it not too broken, I hope I succeeded.

Next up: Arcbound Stinger + Basalt Golem

Up: I don't see much Basalt Golem in this. Reminds me more of Shifting Wall. Defender Modular is definitely an interesting combination.

Not much to work here with. Well at least they both have a flavor I can mash together.
Bloodcrazed Zombies
Creature - Zombie
Bloodcrazed Zombies attacks each combat if able.
Whenever Bloodcrazed Zombies deals combat damage to a player, put a +1/+1 counter on it.
They groaned, they stirred, they all uprose at the first whiff.
2/2

Next: Bladewing the Risen (from Commander Anthology) + Deathforge Shaman(from conspiracy)
(I know, the set doesn't matter. Just thought I'd let you know.)

Up: I like cards that care about creatures with certain keywords, so that's a plus. Also, you misspelt Fellwar Stone.

Azori, Shield of the High Justiciar 
Legendary Enchantment Artifact 
Creatures you control have protection from colors among mana in your opponents' mana pools

Next: Lightning Hounds + Circle of Protection: Art

Up: Good muddle. Wouldn't be surprised if anyone told me this is actually a real Unhinged card.

Infantry Infiltrator
Creature - Human Wizard
, : When target attacking creature deals conbat damage to a player this turn, its controller draws a card.
, : When target attacking creature deals conbat damage to a player this turn, that palyer discards a card.
1/1

Beast token + Worm Token. Wait what? How...?
Let's try this again:
Cloak of Mists + Ichor Slick. Yes, much better.

Up: I would complain about the random inclusion of cycling and madness, but Ichor Slick gave it that problem. Otherwise, a pretty good 1-drop.

Castlewatch Spider 
Creature - Spider Scout 
Reach
When Castlewatch Spider dies, create a 2/4 black Spider creature token with reach.
, Discard Castlewatch Spider: Draw a card, then you lose 1 life.
2/4

Next: Giant Strength + Spawning Pool

Up: When I looked for similar cards, I found Skeletal Grimace. Even though it's (almost) a functional reprint, it's also a good muddle.

Scrib Flickerer
Creature - Rat Wizard
: Exile the top two cards of target player’s library, then put them back in any order.
Whenever a land is exiled from anywhere, untap Scrib Flickerer.
2/2

Next: Voice of Resurgence + Whipkeeper