There are Two Types of Creature on this Card Game

Phyrexagoyf
Three black
Artifact Creature - Phyrexian Lhurgoyf
Infect.
Putrigoyf's power is equal to the number of poison counters on the player with the most poison counters and its toughness is equal to that number plus 1.
*/*+1

Going to have to judge this a bit quickly.


gamma3 An enchantment creature that rewards people playing instants and sorceries - I feel like this is a bit of nonbo design in that regard and that maybe including Enchantment on the typeline actually hurts this entry a bit as it draws away from the type this goyf is supposed to specialize in. I like the use of the Illusion drawback to balance out the fact this type of card would normally check your graveyard only - it could be a good delver-like beatstick in spellslinger decks. Would like to play it.

viriss Unfortunate that it fights to be in the same 4-mana slot as Inverter of Truth, though I suppose there is something you could do with this and
Divining Witch seeing as it is an Eldrazi and thus can be rushed out via Eldrazi Temple. A fairly straightforward mashup of effects that seems to work well enough.


Slight typo (cards not card), btw

dangerousdice - I can't, but I would appreciate an explanation, for what it's worth. It feels like there's a lot going on here though I do like that the sacrifice fuels the back half. Not sure why it is specifically an enchantment though I guess this is the right colors for enchantress strategies.

Nonagon Infinity - The Atogatog route, huh. I like that you made it reference a previous goyf cycle and that it can actively change its P/T to reflect the best situation. Seems like a Commander a lot of people would enjoy.

foureyesisafish - I'm not sure if being very similar to Lord of Extinction was intentional or not. The monocolor identity does at least give it a chance to be used in MonoB commander decks. I would've liked a line of flavortext or a writeup to give this some more depth.

Flo00 - I like that while the effects in question have existed before you use them in a way that feels fresh and the shapeshifter flavor makes me willing to believe it would work in .

hydraheadhunter - Interesting way to promote Infect midrange and political Infect strategies. I appreciate that you didn't use the graveyard and went for something else.

eshix - Wasn't expecting a silver-border entry, but this one is pretty funny. I think the main strike I have against this card is that unnecessary letters might cause a lot of arguments and be hard to count. (From one perspective, cards generally don't care much for names at all, so all letters in the name are not necessary, but from a player that plays cards that names cards, all the letters in the name are necessary.) I think this needs a bit of tweaking before it becomes the ideal party game card it was meant to be - maybe something like unnecessary words in flavor text, or even just counting only cards with flavortext instead. Great spirit, just a little rough around the edges.

Jartis - I like that this fuels itself. Could be particularly fun with eggs decks if they needed and altenrate a wincon (and assuming they're still allowed to exist in any format out there). Feels like with the right cards it could also make for some interesting self-mill strategy. A fairly straightforward entry.

1st: hydraheadhunter
2nd: eshix
3rd: Flo00

Carcinisation - There is a tendency of species on earth to for convergent evolution towards crab-like features; but we've yet to see this play out in MTG Card design (outside the simic guide). Make a card that pairs crab with a creature type it's never been paired with before. Bonus points if your crab-hybrid is not also a simic hybrid.

Inelligible types: Beast, Crocodile, Eldrazi, Elf, Fish, Leviathan, Octopus, Shark, Turtle, Warrior.

Pinchatross
Creature - Bird Crab
Flying
Whenever Pinchatross deals combat damage to a player, that player mills two cards. Draw a card for each land milled this way.
2/1

Thanks for the win! A simple challenge this time; design a creature using the new Phyrexian subtype. It doesn't have to be an unused combination, just anything Phyrexian!

maw-crush

tribal instant - phyrexian warrior

infect, haste

when you cast maw-crush, it deals 3 damage to target creature.

incarnate (you may cast this card for it's incarnate cost. if you do, it becomes a creature as you cast it.)

4/4

Glistening Pest 
Creature - Phyrexian Pest 
Deathtouch
Whenever Glistening Pest attacks, you may pay . If you do, Glistening Pest gets +2/+2 until end of turn. ( can be paid with either or 2 life.)
1/1

Sethy, Rat Monarch
Legendary Creature - Rat Monarch
At the beginning of each end step, surveil X, where X is the number of cards discarded by all players this turn.
Whenever a card leaves a graveyard, each opponent loses 1 life.
1/2

As a real card, this would probably be worded a bit longer to avoid unnecessary triggers in MTGO/Arena. I decided for the classic way with the cleaner text bot. Full modern-style text:
At the beginning of each end step, if a player discarded one or more cards this turn, surveil X, where X is the number of cards discarded by all players this turn. (To surveil X, look at the top X cards of your library, then put any number of them into your graveyard and the rest on top of your library in any order.)
Whenever one or more cards leave graveyards, each opponent loses that much life.