The Enchantment Game

Oops! There are a few challenges waiting on me...



Feedback

Idea : You're right that most enchantments that tap are from Future Sight. I was curious to see what other solutions people come up with. I like your solution to go the land route. It doesn't feel too powerful, and I'm sure in the right environment it would be quite nice. I like it! Good design, the effects fit with the card. It might have been OK to give in indestructible.

viriss : I like this a lot! I wish WotC would do these types of tap enchantments, which are essentially repeatable sorceries. I like that you give the choice here between two modes. Feels well costed too, and a nice flavor win. Cool art too.

elchetibo : I think this should be Legendary, but I'll assume you put that on there to match with the other Shrines. I think with the steep cost to cast and to activate, and that you can only do it once a turn, I think it would be OK to put the Shrine directly into the battlefield.

Winner

viriss with a neat take on what a tap enchantment design could be like.

Multiversal Conquest
Enchantment - Aura
Enchant battle you own
When enchanted battle is defeated, for each opponent, cast a copy of its transformed side.
"I've beaten you once before, so let's skip the pleasantries and give me what I came here for."

Maybe I could cost it more aggressively as battles are already a setup heavy resource slurping endeavor, but I'll keep it how copies are usually costed, 3 mana

Do you perhaps mean "Prevent all non-combat damage that would be dealt to enchanted battle"?

I knew battle auras would be narrow, but i'm glad to see so many different ideas.


Idea Nice Idea. The whole card came together well and feels uncommon powered. I can see this in white/red too. The double X is a real investment in your future.

Daij_Djan The cantrip really sells me on playing this card. I like the "good for me" "bad for you"

melono I'm digging the "you all let this happen" of the 'each opponent'. The cast trigger could also be a payment for each opponent that wasn't a protector. Is that quote from a future Bolas encounter? =)

elchetibo I think you could do that effect in just white. I'm not sure if leaving open non-combat damage is enough.

Flo00 I left the it open to aura's that can also attach to other things and here we are. loop sagas, kill planeswalkers! I like it all.

Thanks for the win! I noticed the other day that the only cards in all of MtG that are both artifacts and enchantments are the Theros god weapons, and one unfinity saga. So for your next challenge, make an enchantment that is also an artifact. I will allow cards that are one on the front side and the other on the back, but it'll be more interesting if they're both on the one card.

Just finished Cyberpunk 2077 yesterday, so I got inspired


Soulkiller
Enchantment Artifact Creature - Virus 

Deathtouch, vigilance.
Whenever ~ fight with another creature, that creature loses indestructible until end of turn. At the end of the turn, if that creature died this turn, put a +1/+1 counter on each creature you control.

5/3

Looks like elchetibo hasn't been here in a while, so I'll define the next challenge as the runner-up.

Next: Design a non-Aura enchantment with flash that doesn't have an enters effect.