Commander Game

I'm going to give emberfire17 the win, with twintania as the runner-up.

I'll give the challenge another week for more entries.

At first I thought I'd just be lazy and slap a doubling season on a legend. Then it evolved into this:

Raela, Peak of Seasons
Legendary Creature - Elf Shaman
If you would put one or more counters on a permanent, put twice that many counters on it instead.
, : Another target creature can block any number of creatures this turn.
1/4

Not that it doesn't matter where you put the counters as long as it is a permanent. You could be throwing extra -1/-1 counters with her as well if you'd like.

Thanks for the win! She was missing P/T, but she is a 1/1.

Next: Two Phyrexian preators (that are not Urabrask) decide to join forces and create a new monstrosity. Create a two color commander that represents that monstrosity.

Megevo, Scavenger of Ideas 
Legendary Creature - Phyrexian Zombie 
At the beginning of your upkeep, exile up to one target nonland card in your graveyard. Copy it. You may cast the copy without paying its mana cost.
, Discard a card: ~ gains hexproof until end of turn.
4/4

---

Genixis: He is intresting, the idea of replacing a card draw with something so different is unexplored. He is an intresting commander for sure, I like the fact he is not as free as say Vorniclex. Maybe the flash thing is a bit unnecesary, feels a bit tacked on but it's not bad. You can see both Vorniclex and Gin kind of tagging along, not a bad mix.

---

Illosophex - Definetly feeling the power here, a 7 mana 7/7 with ward 7 life, flying and lifelink that reanimates something everyturn. It might be a little bit too much, but she is comparable to sheoldred, trading the second ability for flying, lifelink, ward 7 life. But that is kind of my problem, I mean, yeah she can reanimate noncreature permanents and that is cool, but she screams a lot more Sheoldred than Norn. Maybe the ward 7 life could be changed for a more taxy effect like, giving all of your permanents ward 3 mana.

Still, all in all, a solid commander.

---

Urabrask: This feels too low impact. This is a very very expensive vigilance for your team and a weaker ghostly prision kind of card. Honestly, I'd remove the pay part of it, just make it so it gives your creatures vigilance and exerts creatures your opponents control when they attack. That is pretty fitting I think. Also, kind of weird for him not to have haste. Still I like the idea.

---

Magevo: Jeez, this card is just too good. I mean, yeah, you do have to untap with it, but if you do, it's really strong. At its worst, it can let you play any card of your hand for mana at the start of your turn. It can reanimate creatures, artifacts, enchantments. It can cast instants and sorceries (which is very scary) for free from your graveyard. And once you untap with him, the game is over, you can just protect him. I feel the second ability is unnecesary, or should be changed for something much softer. It shoould cost more and/or have some kind of mana restriction. That said, this feels like the only entry where it feels like a Gin and Sheoldred worked together and created something, as it echos some aspects of both.

Solid commanders, I'll give the win to Flo00

Thanks for the win my lord!

Next challenge: Choose any preconstructed commander deck and make a new commander for it!

I probably gonna forget this if I don't judge now. Sadly, there is only one entry.

raphiezar I like experience counters. I think this throws them around a little too fast. In your usual four player commander game with an agressive deck this can pootentially give you three XP during each of your turns. What I think is very smart yet probably also a bit confusing is that myriad won't up the count. At least I think it doesn't, since you don't declare the tokens as attackes.

You won by default, so go for it.

Dinosaur landfall and enrage tribal, it's everything I could ever want in a card.