Planeswalker Game

{kefke }I love the "Prowess" ability on the +1, and the -6 is a good turn 3 ult that isn't too earthshattering. As for the middle ability, I could take it or leave it. It's good, and in-color for red, it just doens't feel incredibly Jeskai, which I have to assume was the inspiration. For the record, I also enjoy how the +1 provides a bit of ramp to colors that don't usually ramp. (Red has some but it's usually pretty self-destructive.)

{gluestick248 }Not much to say here. He does Ajani things, he does them in the right colors. He's not gonna win games but you're probably never gonna be sad to see him in your hand. I don't feel like there's any balance issues. It's a solid card, but maybe not a first pack draft pick, unless you're really confident in your ability to build a three color mana base. Depends on the set, I suppose. If he's at rare, he's good, if he's at mythic, I'd say he's maybe below the power curve a bit.

{Tesagk }Sorry for the wall, but more complicated abilities require more analysis. First off, I don't think it would be too bad to deal with, but I could see some people complaining about the bookkeeping the ETB requires, especially in a multiplayer game with several players running this card. As for the first ability, I'm not sure if you need to note that you can only choose an option once, not really sure about the syntax there, but I'll be judging based on that assumption. The middle ability is good by itself, but in relation to the whole card I have some issues, namely, two of the three abilities it grants are different from your ETB options. This, to me, does two things. 1. It makes vigilance a less-appealing option for the ETB. 2. It creates mental keyword soup, even if only for a turn. Now the ultimate ability is something I can really get behind. It's a big ability, it's flavorful and in color, it comes out at the right speed, and it will really make a difference in the game without just being an "I win" button.

{Flo00 }Boy, those are weird hybrid costs. XD It took me a second of looking at them to really comprehend, but that could be because I just woke up. So, first ability, I'm not entirely sure about the ruling on this, but to me it seems like you couldn't activate this ability if there were no tapped creatures on the board? Or you would have to target your own tapped creature if that's the only option. Second ability, +3/+3 and two combat keywords for a -1? I don't think I like that. It seems incredibly powerful, especially considering you can do it six times before Anyu kills itself (more on that later). The ult is a superpowered wall that outright kills some attackers, freezes the rest, and doesn't even have a way around it like paying some cost. Now that may have been alright...if it couldn't come out in three turns. 4 mana for a 6 loyalty 'walker that has such a strong ult at 8 loyalty seems way overtuned to me. Especially since, as long as you're not playing commander, it fits in Mono-W, Azorius, Boros, Izzet, or Jeskai decks, and is even pretty playable in any other deck that splashes white. Normally I'd be a fan of that playability, but if it's going to be as strong as it is, I think I'd like it to be a bit harder to play.

{fluffydeathbringer }I do like Alesha as a character. The graveyard recursion is pretty unusual for planeswalkers, I like it. It's a five turn ult, and a pretty powerful one. I'd maybe bump the cost by 1, but overall the theme of not only Alesha conquering death, but helping others conquer death as well is really great, with the added +1/+1 counters to make it useful in a wider variety of decks.

{Xenozfan2 }I like the idea of keeping Urza WUBRG. Since all of his abilities hinge on his ult, I'm gonna focus on that. First, it comes out in 3 turns. Since it's exiling lands, potentially incredibly late in the game, it's already probably a bit too powerful for my liking, especially coming out as fast as it does. Second, since the 0 loyalty check is a state based action, the exile will resolve before Urza is sacrificed, which is probably intentional, but just means that he gets to come out and be janky all over again. And it can be done for free because of the emblem's upkeep ability, too. I think I get what you were going for, since it functions similarly (and at the same speed as) Karn Liberated, but Karn requires that you use his other abilities a bit to get full use out of his ult. That said, ultimately, it just seems like it would slow the game down unnecessarily, and that's not particularly fun Magic to most people.

{mrlozano }My main problem with the first ability is that artifacts are historic, and incredibly easy to get. In fact, this thing's ult creates a ton more of them, making this an incredibly efficient token generator. Maybe a bit too efficient. The middle ability is nice, and I believe well costed. The ult, as I mentioned before, is powerful. It puts Nahiri to shame as an equip-based Planeswalker. That said, given that it requires the equipment to enter the battlefield, and likely around turn 10 or so, I don't think it's actually /too/ broken. I could be way off on that, but I think it's fun, and I'd at least like to see it happen in a game before judging it too harshly.

{Winners:}This time I'm gonna give the win to fluffydeathbringer , with the runners-up mrlozano and kefke . Fun round, all. I hope we see more official 'walkers in these combinations soon ^-^