Zodiac Set

welcome to the forums. you can link images by first hosting them on an external website and then image linking the image address through the little photograph icon at the top of the post window

the thing with making four-color sets is that either you just straightup slice off a piece of mechanical color pie and leave the set gutted of a key mechanical aspect (bad) or reassign the effects that color has access to to other colors (better). the latter intrinsically requires one to bend or break color pie as initially conceived of by most people as you make a new, four-color pie, so it pays to think carefully about what effect you give to what color and what you're going to base that on mechanically and/or flavourfully. that said, here are my thoughts on your attempt to redistribute black's mechanics across the other colors

- fire's fine

- water's where my issues begin. you've taken stuff from other colors that you didn't really need to take out (damage prevention and lifelink/lifegain from white, reach from green) and stuck it onto blue which strikes me as entirely unnecessary. I argue that all these traits of water can easily be expressed by sticking to blue's part of the color pie (-X/-0 effects, scry, hexproof for example) with only minor additions. and even if we go with flavour why does the element of protecton, nurture, and emotion have deathtouch of all things

- and then air. why is air, the element of intellectualism, not blue, the color of the mind in mtg. why did you gut blue's card draw and stick it into white, the color with mechanically the worst card draw. why give white, a color with no hand disruption whatsoever, discard. the color pie exists for a reason, to give all colors their weaknesses so no one superior color will dominate gameplay. giving white these things undermines these weaknesses without introducing any new ones. why such a drastic change in color pie? this goes beyond redistributing black's pie to other colors and into territory that looks like messing with pie for the sake of messing with pie without understanding why pie exists in the first place.

- earth's relatively fine, giving it black's share of menace feels like an alright bend that doesn't undermine green's mechanical weaknesses (e.g. not being able to deal with creatures without using creatures of your own, no hand attack, third best in card draw)

if you need associated types for virgo, libra, and aquarius, I'd suggest Cleric, Advisor, and Elemental respectively

Thank you for the responses!

Regarding the colour wheel, my approach is not to move things around for the sake of messing with it, but rather to look at the 4 philosophical elements and try to understand them in terms of mtg mechanics. In vanilla MTG it seems fire and earth are red and green, thus that translation happens easier. Air seems to be blue in vanilla, with flying and control, while water seems to be spread out across white and green. So in a sense I guess blue and white switch around, I didn't want to make water white and air blue, that would be weird. I could go make 4 custom mana symbols with different colours, but it's easier just using these. I thus stand by air being control and water being lifegain, swapping the vanilla aspect of that colour wheel. Now the colour wheel is very important since it is so nicely balanced, and changing it in this way will require more work to have a balanced 4 colours, but I'll just have to playtest until it works.

A difficulty for me in this is to do both the Zodiac and the 4 Elements, since there are sometimes mismatches. For example, look at Oracle's Secrets, which is card draw in Earth. Air, being the intellectual, should have the card draw, but at the same time Virgo is associated with secrets, so I feel it should have card draw, but Virgo is an Earth sign. There are deeper philosophical aspects to all this, and it might be too complex to represent in an MTG card, so I should just simplify it to sort of represent the philosophy while also remaining sensible and fun.

Another problem here is Deathtouch in Water, I agree it seems awkward. Now I'm not sure which element poison and venom would be associated with, it is not fire or air, but it could be either water or earth. Venom and poison are usually in liquid form, but are also found in earthy animals, so it's tough. I would say that perhaps the effect of the venom plays a role, if we look at humorism in ancient Greek medicine (which nicely complements this theme), the body is made up of 4 elements. Now health is when those elements are in balance, while sickness comes when they are out of balance (Fever = too much fire, diarrhea = too much water). Medicine seeks to change the balance, as does poison, and therefore the difference is only dosage and balance of patient. Giving medicine which boosts the fire element to a person with diarrhea will help, but to a person with fever might kill them. Thus when a snake bites you, from this perspective the question is, what kind of venom is it? I don't know much about snake venom, but say the venom clots the blood so much that it can't flow, that would be raising the earth element, or it stops the blood from clotting and you bleed to death, that would be raising the water element. So either of the 4 elements can be venom and therefore deathtouch, I think. The reason I have it in Water is Scorpio. The story of Scorpio is that a scorpion stung young Horus, God of Egypt, and it killed him. His mom was crying out to the Gods and Thoth came down to raise Horus back to life. This represents initiation and transformation, the death of the old self and birth of the new self, and a poisonous sting is what facilitates it. This is why I thought that Deathtouch belongs in Water, along with the fact that some of the most venomous creatures reside in the oceans or waters of jungles. But I'm still open to changing this, perhaps once I've created all the creatures we'll have a look at how they measure up to the other 3 elements.

Flying obviously belongs to air, and the question of reach is also difficult. I gave reach to Fire and Water, but not Earth, as the opposite element it should be weak to it. But it does make sense that Earth should also get Reach, I'll look into it. I have been wondering about adding a Swimming keyword, which is the same as flying but in Water. Then there is Islandwalk/Forestwalk/Landwalk thing which I don't have but seems to be related to this. I'll have to go think about evasion and counter evasion, including intimidate and menace and unblockable, to create a nice play/counter-play relationship among the 4 elements.

Cat makes sense for Leo

Do you guys have any recommendations for where to host pictures so I can post more cards?